Tags
arthshastra, chanakya, chandragupta, crime and punishment, danda-neeti, draupadi, eloquence, governance, hair, Mahabharata, sama-dama-danda-bheda, shikha
The exotic and fiery Empress of Indraprastha. {5000 B.C.E}
The homely and cool headed diplomat cum Kingmaker. {370 B.C.E}
What possible thread could bind them?
I] The loosened HAIR, the oath for REVENGE:
Chanakya was insulted in full court by King Dhanananda. Stung at this barb, Chanakya unfurled his shikha (knotted braid) and swore not to tie it until Dhanananda’s evil rule was demolished.
Sounds FAMILIAR?
Draupadi, heinously insulted in Hastinapur’s court. Verbally, physically and psychologically – swore not to braid her hair until her sinners, the Kauravas were avenged in battle.
In both cases, their righteous rage led to a ‘Constructive Destruction’, i.e destruction of evil for the sake of dharma.
II] Eloquence:
Chanakya, highly LEARNED in politics, religion, science, legal system, astronomy, geography and mathematics. His Chanakya –neeti one–liners trend as quotable quotes to this day.
As for Draupadi, who can forget her blistering speech at the dice game of Hastinapur? She scoured logic, dharma and shastras. Her questions transformed the atmosphere from brutality to logic.
Her assertive question, ‘If Yudhisthir had pledged himself first, how can I still be pledged or won?’ still remains unanswered across 5000 years.
III] Efficient Governance:
Unfortunately, debates around Draupadi begin and end at her polyandry. Unfortunate that many cannot elevate their mind beyond the mundane.
Her conversation with Satyabhama in Vana-Parva, however highlights her amazing efficiency.
Draupadi, the Administrator, Personnel Manager & Organizational Wizard:
Quote, ‘1,00,000 maids employed in my husbands’ palaces and 1,00,000 maids waiting upon Indraprastha’s guests. I knew the names and features of all those girls. I was the one who regulated their number and framed the rules to be observed in respect of them.
Indeed, I knew everything about what the maid-servants, the other classes of attendants, even the cow-herds and the shepherds of the royal establishment, did or did not.’ she says with casual competence.
Draupadi, the C.A & Treasurer – “I alone knew the income and expenditure of Indraprasth’s King and what their whole wealth was. I alone supervised their treasury inexhaustible like the ever-filled receptacle of Varuna.’’
Chanakya’s “Arthshastra” is the final word in monetary and fiscal policies, public welfare, international relations and war strategies in detail. He was the ‘Mastermind’ behind mighty Chandragupta, whose Maurya Empire stretched across the length and width of Bharat.
IV] Justice and Danda-Niti:
Here is Draupadi speaking to Krishn, “Nothing would come out of SAMA, conciliation with the Kauravas, nor from DAMA, charity to them. With men not open to conciliation or charity there is only one way if you want to protect your life: DANDA, violence, use of force.
“Those who know dharma understand that it is as much a sin NOT to punish those who deserve punishment as to punish those who do not deserve it.”
Although Chanakya advocated SAMA-DAMA-DANDA-BHED, he completely agreed with Draupadi on Justice.
He says, ‘Whoever imposes severe punishment becomes repulsive to the people; while he who awards mild punishment becomes contemptible. But whoever imposes PUNISHMENT AS DESERVED becomes respectable.
“Dandaniti requires state power to protect the weak against coercion and exploitation by the mighty. Otherwise there would be no good and honest men left in the world.’
V] Both were Vishu devotees
Chanakya was also known as Vishnugupta. His Arthshastra begins with a tribute to Vishnu.
Draupadi , escalating beyond bhakti-rasa, was immersed in maitra-rasa (friendship) with Krishn (Vishnu avatar).
Do you think the striking similarities are mere co-incidence?
Do you know other historical figures with comparative life events?

Such an informative post!!
LikeLike
Thank you Ruma! Always feels nice to be appreciated.
I am a great fan of both these personalities.
LikeLiked by 1 person
I think it is unfair to compare Chanakya with Draupadi and the similarities drawn out here are mere co-incidences.
LikeLike
Ah, good to see a difference of opinion. Variety makes the spice of life.
According to you, the comparison is unfair to Chanakya or to Draupadi? I would love to know the opinion behind the opinion.
I find both these personas very intense and interesting. Perhaps my adulation for both led me to seize upon their similarities. Eagerly awaiting your reply!
LikeLike
Reblogged this on Avi + Random and commented:
Beautiful Post by Dr Sweety Shinde
LikeLike
Delighted and honored! Thank you very much Avi.
LikeLike
Your welcome. Really loved your post 🙂
LikeLike
Awww, delighted! Hope I keep churning out better and better material. Thanx again for the reblog.
LikeLike
Interesting read. Good to draw out parallels between characters sometimes.
LikeLike
Hi, Thanx for the follow.
Yes, just as historians have found parallels between Odysseus and Krishn, Chanakya and Machiavelli etc. Great personalities certainly lend themselves to comparisons.
LikeLike
beautiful post.. n vry informative..
LikeLike
Hey Haritha! So nice to see you here on my virtual space.
Glad that you enjoyed the post. Do keep coming back. I’ll do my best to hold your attention.
Take care, dear.
LikeLike
🙂 Interesting observations. Enjoyed reading this.
LikeLiked by 1 person
Hi Parwati,
So glad you gave a thumbs up. I wasn’t sure whether the comparison would find takers. Overjoyed to have provided the stimulus. Thank you!
LikeLike
Hi Parwati. For some reason, clicking on your name or blog url takes me to an error message. Have you changed your blog url?
Please do update me, or update on your blog profile.
LikeLiked by 1 person
No, I shall check this out. Thanks for bringing this to my notice.
LikeLike
Yes, please do. Even hovering my cursor over your Gravatar image does not transport me to your blog. Could you give me your url, please?
LikeLike
Thanks for the excellent post. I like Draupadi’s stand. The answer to violence is violence and not Sama or Dama.
Talking about similarities, I can tell you one. There are a lot of similarities between late Presidents, Abraham Lincoln and John Kennedy. Please read this link. Thanks.
http://www.snopes.com/history/american/lincoln-kennedy.asp
LikeLike
Ah, somebody stole my bright idea in advance! Haha. Hmm, I would have never thought to compare JFK and Lincoln, but it does make sense.
As for violence, yes. We have too many people defending the criminals under the guise of ‘human rights’.
For me, that is like saying that the victims are sub-human and deserve no human rights. Shielding a criminal is denying justice to victims. Period.
LikeLike
Very interesting… It takes lots of courage & wit to do such comparison. You are exceptional, Sweety. It doesn’t seem odd at any place. Kudos
LikeLiked by 1 person
I am delighted at your praise.
I love both Chanakya and Draupadi. Once the ‘shikha’comparison lit up my brain, the rest seemed so obvious.
Thank you, once again.
LikeLiked by 1 person
Pingback: Book Cover Design – why, what, how? | Impractical Dreamer
what an analysis! i loved this post, it is so different and amazing! 🙂
LikeLike
Thank you! Isn’t it amazing to find such crucial nexus points between epic characters? Sometimes I wonder if they are re-incarnations, carrying on their destined task in another life as well. Do you?
LikeLiked by 1 person
yes, sometimes i do 🙂
LikeLike